Skip to main content

Table 3 Coherence, Cv, UMass, and \(C_{UCI}\) scores of topics on \(G'\) against cutting and weighting models

From: Improving topic modeling through homophily for legal documents

Model

\(G', w_n, w_j\)

Coherence

Cv

UMass

\(C_{UCI}\)

LDA

 

0.131

0.509

\(-\) 0.457

\(-\) 4.476

RTM

\(w \rightarrow \infty\)

0.159

0.611

\(-\) 0.412

\(-\) 1.078

Cutting

\(w_n^P \, \ge\) 0, \(w_n^S \, \ge\) 0

0.163

0.616

\(-\) 0.394

\(-\) 1.061

 

\(w_n^P \, \ge\) 5, \(w_n^S \, \ge\) 10

0.163

0.619

\(-\) 0.395

\(-\) 1.029

 

\(w_j^P \, \ge\) 0.50, \(w_j^S \, \ge\) 0.25

0.167

0.613

\(-\) 0.402

\(-\) 1.057

Weighting

\(w_j^P + w_j^S\)

0.165

0.620

\(-\) 0.387

\(-\) 1.031

 

\(w_j^P \times w_j^S\)

0.174

0.610

\(-\) 0.419

\(-\) 1.052

 

\(T_{H,0}(w_j^P, w_j^S)\)

0.173

0.607

\(-\) 0.416

\(-\) 1.083

 

\(T_{Y,1}(w_j^P, w_j^S)\)

0.174

0.622

\(-\)0.371

\(-\) 1.030

 

\(T_{E}(w_j^P, w_j^S)\)

0.171

0.614

\(-\) 0.395

\(-\) 1.030

 

\(w_s^P + w_s^S\)

0.172

0.619

\(-\) 0.387

\(-\) 1.020

 

\(w_s^P \times w_s^S\)

0.170

0.614

\(-\) 0.392

\(-\) 1.050

 

\(T_{H,0}(w_s^P, w_s^S)\)

0.171

0.613

\(-\) 0.402

\(-\) 1.082

 

\(T_{Y,1}(w_s^P, w_s^S)\)

0.171

0.617

\(-\) 0.399

\(-\) 1.055

 

\(T_{E}(w_s^P, w_s^S)\)

0.171

0.620

\(-\) 0.387

\(-\)1.012